Ensuring that the peer review is done properly by capturing some remarks by the reviewer. | Voters

Enate

Create

Roadmap

Feature Suggestion

289

Ensuring that the peer review is done properly by capturing some remarks by the reviewer.

closed

Tijana Starcevic

As a user, I would like to make "Action Peer Review Comments" field as mandatory before the peer review action can be closed. This is to ensure that the user doesn't just simply close the peer review action without adding any remark.

March 26, 2021

Kamal Saran

marked this post as

closed

Kamal Saran

Hi All,
We are not going to build this on the platform for now. As this may create complexity and usability concerns for our other users.
However, you can achieve the business outcome by building a peer review specific checklist to remind the reviewer to check certain things part of the review. The checklist also forces the user to mark it as Yes/No/Na before they can pass the review.
Thanks
Kamal

Kamal Saran

marked this post as

product review

Kamal Saran

Tijana Starcevic - Thanks for the feedback. we do ask the user to enter the comment if they fail the review. if pass/happy path scenario , it's counter intuaitive to ask for comment when all looks good. it will add one more extra step in day-to-day job. 
please let me know your views on this . 
thanks,
Kamal.